Loading Session...

Redefining Units: Reflections on the 2018 Reform of the Metric System

Session Information

On November 16, 2018 the General Conference on Weights and Measures plans to announce a major revision to the International System of Units (SI; known colloquially as the 'metric system'). Four base SI units - the kilogram, ampere, mole and kelvin - will be redefined by fixing the numerical values of four fundamental constants: the Planck constant, the electron charge, the Avogadro constant and the Boltzmann constant, respectively. The culmination of three decades of debate and preparation in the metrological community, the metric reform will abolish the existing definition of the kilogram as the mass of a platinum-iridium cylinder kept at a vault near Paris, and with it the dependence of SI unit definitions on concrete artefacts. This symposium, held just two weeks before the new definitions take effect, will reflect on the ontological, epistemic and semantic implications of the metric reform. We will critically examine the rationale behind detaching unit definitions from reference to concrete objects; determine how scientific progress can be made through acts of definition; discuss the apparent circularity of testing fundamental theoretical laws with a system of measurement that presupposes those very laws; and explore the broader implications of the redefinition for the philosophy of science.

04 Nov 2018 09:00 AM - 11:45 AM(America/Los_Angeles)
Venue : Diamond B (First Floor)
20181104T0900 20181104T1145 America/Los_Angeles Redefining Units: Reflections on the 2018 Reform of the Metric System

On November 16, 2018 the General Conference on Weights and Measures plans to announce a major revision to the International System of Units (SI; known colloquially as the 'metric system'). Four base SI units - the kilogram, ampere, mole and kelvin - will be redefined by fixing the numerical values of four fundamental constants: the Planck constant, the electron charge, the Avogadro constant and the Boltzmann constant, respectively. The culmination of three decades of debate and preparation in the metrological community, the metric reform will abolish the existing definition of the kilogram as the mass of a platinum-iridium cylinder kept at a vault near Paris, and with it the dependence of SI unit definitions on concrete artefacts. This symposium, held just two weeks before the new definitions take effect, will reflect on the ontological, epistemic and semantic implications of the metric reform. We will critically examine the rationale behind detaching unit definitions from reference to concrete objects; determine how scientific progress can be made through acts of definition; discuss the apparent circularity of testing fundamental theoretical laws with a system of measurement that presupposes those very laws; and explore the broader implications of the redefinition for the philosophy of science.

Diamond B (First Floor) PSA2018: The 26th Biennial Meeting of the Philosophy of Science Association office@philsci.org

Presentations

The New SI? Trade-Offs in Empirical Determinability

Philosophy of Science 09:00 AM - 09:30 AM (America/Los_Angeles) 2018/11/04 17:00:00 UTC - 2018/11/04 17:30:00 UTC
Jo E. Wolff (King's College London)
Changing the definitions of SI units changes what can be known empirically and what is fixed by definition. In this talk I address whether we have reason to be concerned about removing the numerical value of fundamental constants like Planck's constant and the speed of light in vacuum from empirical determination. I do so by comparing definitions in terms of fundamental constants with definitions in terms of prototypes (as in the case of the old definition of the kilogram) and definitions in terms of non-fundamental constants (as in the case of the mole).
Presenters
JW
Jo Wolff
King's College London

Economies of Uncertainty: Philosophical Lessons from the Metric Reform

Philosophy of Science 09:30 AM - 10:00 AM (America/Los_Angeles) 2018/11/04 17:30:00 UTC - 2018/11/04 18:00:00 UTC
Eran Tal (McGill University)
The upcoming redefinition of metric units may strike philosophers as counterintuitive. How can the uncertainties associated with some fundamental constants be reduced through definition alone? Answering this and related puzzles calls for a reconsideration of the epistemic goals of metrology. Besides amassing new knowledge, I argue that metrology is also concerned with managing ignorance. Ignorance claims, like knowledge claims, are underdetermined by data, and depend on auxiliary assumptions for their testing. The upcoming metric reform involves a shift in these assumptions, and hence a redistribution of uncertainty among evidentially connected empirical claims.
Presenters
ET
Eran Tal
McGill University

The Social and Theoretical Fabric of Fundamental Constants in the New SI: An Epistemological Analysis

Philosophy of Science 10:15 AM - 10:45 AM (America/Los_Angeles) 2018/11/04 18:15:00 UTC - 2018/11/04 18:45:00 UTC
Nadine de Courtenay (Université Paris Diderot)
Far from pertaining to mere convention, the redefinition of base units in terms of fundamental constants entails assumptions about the validity of existing theories. These assumptions surface (i) in a social work of deliberation and calculation designed to ensure the coherence of future measurement results in the new system; and (ii) in implicit theoretical claims about the fusion of quantities that were previously thought to be distinct. This talk will bring out the ways in which these social and theoretical levels of scientific construction get articulated into a historical process of learning that highlights the epistemological role of fundamental constants.
Presenters Nadine De Courtenay
University Paris Diderot (Sorbonne Paris Cit?)

Stepping Away from the SI: The Case of Quantum Electrical Metrology

Philosophy of Science 10:45 AM - 11:15 AM (America/Los_Angeles) 2018/11/04 18:45:00 UTC - 2018/11/04 19:15:00 UTC
Fabien Gregis (Cohn Institute, Tel Aviv University)
The successive discoveries of the Josephson effect (1962) and the quantum Hall effect (1980) revolutionized electrical measurements and opened the era of quantum electrical metrology. It enabled physicists to perform much more accurate measurements by designing new ad hoc electrical standards, which were commonly adopted by convention in 1990. However, by doing so, electrical metrology stepped away from the International System of Units (SI), only to rejoin it with the upcoming SI reform. This presentation explores the epistemological issues related to the adoption of the quantum electrical units and their justification.
Presenters
FG
Fabien Grégis
Cohn Institute, Tel Aviv University

Three Philosophical Approaches to Measurement

Philosophy of Science 11:15 AM - 11:45 AM (America/Los_Angeles) 2018/11/04 19:15:00 UTC - 2018/11/04 19:45:00 UTC
Robert Crease (Stony Brook University)
This talk uses the metric reform to highlight differences between three traditions in the philosophy of measurement — analytic, pragmatic, and continental. These philosophical traditions have different perspectives on science in somewhat the way physicists, chemists, and engineers have different perspectives on atoms: different features are put center-stage, and analyzed in different vocabularies for different ends. These traditions bring different kinds of expertise to the subject of measurement, and scrutinize in detail different features. I analyze the way each tradition would view the looming metric reform, and use this analysis to clarify each tradition's presuppositions, goals and implications.
Presenters
RC
Robert Crease
Stony Brook University
698 visits

Session Participants

Online
Session speakers, moderators & attendees
McGill University
King's College London
University Paris Diderot (Sorbonne Paris Cit?)
Cohn Institute, Tel Aviv University
Stony Brook University
McGill University
No attendee has checked-in to this session!
22 attendees saved this session

Session Chat

Live Chat
Chat with participants attending this session

Questions & Answers

Answered
Submit questions for the presenters

Session Polls

Active
Participate in live polls

Need Help?

Technical Issues?

If you're experiencing playback problems, try adjusting the quality or refreshing the page.

Questions for Speakers?

Use the Q&A tab to submit questions that may be addressed in follow-up sessions.